Hour 1
Kurt Patat from AOL on American Idol. He disagreed with Simon on round 1 - it should've gone to David Cook. Round 2 was the weakest. David Cook definitely should have done Billie Jean or Hello instead of the song he chose for round 3. Why did Simon build up Cook on so many talk shows, only to tear him down last night? What does the future hold for American Idol? Check out the results of the ultimate American Idol poll at tv.aol.com to see which judge fans think should go, whether it should be "Seacrest out" for good, and other changes that might be good for the show.

Hour 2
David Lawrence with Rocky Mirza.

Hour 3
David Lawrence with Peter Watkins.

Audio
Click to listen now, or right click to save to your computer.

- Hour 1
- Hour 2
- Hour 3
- Full 3 hours